>
The role of the permanent wilting point in controlling the spatial distribution of precipitation
https://www.pnas.org/content/115/22/5692#sec-1Significance
One basic distinction between land and ocean is that the land can dry out. We show that this is of fundamental importance for the precipitation distribution over land as it brings precipitation from the precipitating region to the nonprecipitating region. This process prevents the land–atmosphere system from sustaining precipitation over the same region and thus acts against drought or the formation of desert. Paradoxically, although dry atmospheres are known to hamper moist convection, drying the soil to its permanent wilting point generates circulations that are strong enough to overcome this inhibition. Our findings help understand why tropical rain bands broaden poleward over land, the more so the drier the soils are.
Abstract
Convection-permitting simulations on an idealized land planet are performed to understand whether soil moisture acts to support or impede the organization of convection. Initially, shallow circulations driven by differential radiative cooling induce a self-aggregation of the convection into a single band, as has become familiar from simulations over idealized sea surfaces. With time, however, the drying of the nonprecipitating region induces a reversal of the shallow circulation, drawing the flow at low levels from the precipitating to the nonprecipitating region. This causes the precipitating convection to move over the dry soils and reverses the polarity of the circulation. The precipitation replenishes these soils with moisture at the expense of the formerly wet soils which dry, until the process repeats itself. On longer timescales, this acts to homogenize the precipitation field. By analyzing the strength of the shallow circulations, the surface budget with its effects on the boundary layer properties, and the shape of the soil moisture resistance function, we demonstrate that the soil has to dry out significantly, for the here-tested resistance formulations below 15% of its water availability, to be able to alter the precipitation distribution. We expect such a process to broaden the distribution of precipitation over tropical land. This expectation is supported by observations which show that in drier years the monsoon rains move farther inland over Africa.
Physically, the ability of soil moisture to store water and lose water in interaction with the atmosphere affects the partitioning between sensible and latent heat flux and through this the precipitation distribution in two potentially opposing ways. First, a change in the Bowen ratio affects the stability of the atmosphere and hence the triggering of convection. The most common response is that an increase in soil moisture favors the triggering of convection (18, 19) and hence increases precipitation. Following this argument, soil moisture maintains precipitation in the precipitating region. Second, the spatially localized nature of convective precipitation leads to the development of soil moisture gradients. Gradients in soil moisture lead to gradients in sensible heat flux, which can thermally induce a shallow circulation with surface flow from the wet to the dry region. This circulation can lead to the triggering of convection over the dry region (20, 21), a phenomenon that has been in particular observed in the Sahel region (22), although its signature has been deciphered globally (23). Following this second argument, soil moisture brings precipitation to the nonprecipitating region.
The below are all extracts from within the paper.
Soil Moisture Brings Precipitation to the Nonprecipitating Region
We use a simple formulation for the land surface in our simulations, a formulation that retains the two key characteristics of soil moisture (Materials and Methods): its spatial and temporal variability through the action of precipitation and evaporation as well as its nonlinear control on the surface fluxes via the use of a resistance formulation (Eq. 5). This model version is compared with a version where the soil moisture resistance is set to zero, mimicking the situation of an infinite supply of water.
In our simulations, convection rapidly develops and produces precipitation with a daily mean of around 4.6 mm⋅d−1. The spatial distribution of precipitation (Fig. 1) indicates that in both model versions convection organizes as time proceeds. That convection spontaneously begins to self-aggregate into a large convective structure is a well-known feature from past RCE simulations, as noted previously. Interactive soil moisture leads to little difference between the simulations up to around day 60. The monthly mean precipitating area, calculated from days 25 to 55, occupies 76% of the domain in both simulations. Hence, during this time period, the precipitation distribution is fully controlled by the atmosphere. This is consistent with values of the atmospheric resistance rara that are much larger than values of the soil moisture resistance rsrs, for instance 100 times larger at noon.
The Spatial Distribution of Precipitation Is Fully Determined by Shallow Circulations
We investigate the processes determining the spatial distribution of precipitation, in particular those leading to its homogenization by soil moisture. We focus on the simulation with interactive soil moisture around day 60.
The self-aggregation of convection, before day 60, is due to a shallow circulation (Fig. 2A) that spins up in the boundary layer due to the distinct radiative heating profiles of the nonprecipitating and the precipitating region
The circulation maintains the convection aggregated in one band with minimal changes in direction (Fig. 3A). Around day 60, however, the circulation pattern drastically changes and begins to converge into the previously nonprecipitating region (Figs. 2B and 3A), called the desiccated region.
Following the altered circulation pattern, precipitation starts falling on the desiccated region of the domain around day 60 (Figs. 2 and 3) and the two circulation forcings work hand in hand. As the precipitation replenishes the soil moisture, the surface forcing disappears in less than 10 d (Figs. 2 B and C and 3C). The radiatively driven circulation nevertheless maintains the new precipitation distribution until dry enough areas form in other parts of the domain and steal the precipitation (Fig. 2 C and D). This results in a permanent back and forth between the radiatively driven circulation, which wants to organize the convection in one place, and the soil moisture-induced circulation, which wants to disorganize the convection
Summary
Letting radiation, convection, and soil moisture interact with each other in an initially homogeneous land–atmosphere system indicates that the fundamental role of soil moisture is to bring precipitation from the precipitating to the nonprecipitating region.
much more within paper…..which I assume is still dry.