Arctic Sea Ice has a very small volume, but in relation big extent/area with this constellation the minimum for extent will be later this season.
You are quite correct that the freezing season has not begun -- the best available evidence, which seems to be at the links below, shows
net melt everywhere out through August 27th. It is better to wait on NSIDC's call than go charging off on divisive new forums out of synch with the scientific community.
I am skeptical that anyone here is running more sophisticated models than ESRL. Most people here are not running any model at all and indeed lack access to the necessary computing resources. It is usually better to defer to those with far greater skill sets -- unless you can specifically document problems with their products and link to your conflicting data.
Meanwhile I received an update today on the wonderful new ESRL forecast page from Dr. Janet M Intrieri, deputy branch chief scientist at NOAA.
https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/forecasts/seaice/ new page
https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/forecasts/seaice/model_validation/ hindcast validation
ftp://ftp1.esrl.noaa.gov/RASM-ESRL/ModelOutput all-important new archive with netCDFs
https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/forecasts/seaice/skill_assessment/ 2016 freezeup skill
https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/people/amy.solomon/seaice.html all-in-one old page
"These 0-10 day, experimental sea ice forecasts are produced by the NOAA Physical Sciences Division from a fully coupled ice-ocean-atmosphere model called RASM-ESRL. RASM-ESRL is run daily and posted online at 2 UTC [seeking clarification on 2:00 vs 14:00].
The model is initialized with the NOAA Global Forecast System (GFS) analyses and the Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer 2 (AMSR2) sea ice concentrations. The model is forced at the lateral boundaries by 3-hourly GFS forecasts of winds, temperature, and water vapor.
RASM-ESRL, adapted from the Regional Arctic System Model (Maslowski et al. 2012) was modified for short-term, weather-scale forecasts and includes the following model components: the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF3.5.1; run with 40 vertical levels) atmospheric model; the Parallel Ocean Program (POP2) model; the Los Alamos Community Ice Model (CICE 5.1, Hunke et al. 2013); and the NCAR Community Land Model (CLM4.5).
All components, run at 10 km horizontal resolution, are coupled using a regionalized version of the CESM flux coupler (CPL7), which includes modifications (Roberts et al. 2014) important for
resolving the sea ice pack response to weather events.Other model optimizations include: a bulk double-moment cloud microphysics scheme for droplets and frozen hydrometeors (Morrison et al. 2009), running ensemble forecasts initialized with GEFS ensemble members, and extending the model domain to include the Bering Strait and Svalbard.
https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/data-access/model-data/model-datasets/global-ensemble-forecast-system-gefs 21 ensemble members
New for 2017:
Extended domain includes Bering Strait [confirming they mean Barents Sea here]
Ice thickness initialization uses spring CryoSat-2
Weekly sea ice concentration updates with AMSR-2
Ensemble runs using GEFS members (in progress)
Updated website with new guidance products, meteograms, and cross-sections
We greatly appreciate feedback on products you find useful or requests for any additional fields you would like to see on the web page. Model output is continually being evaluated. Please visit the site for updated information on skill, ensemble performance, and comparisons with observations as the freeze-up season progresses."