Edit: Data from PIOMAS which is also updated now.
Thanks for this. I have just quickly cobbled up two images showing PIOMAS vs SAT-SLP for both halves of May, for the four largest droppers on record 2010, 2012, 2016, 2019. The volume decrease in km3 is below the year.
My interpretation for May 1-15:
2010 lost the most volume, because of the extremely high pressure over the Central Arctic and lots of heat along the Siberian coast. For 2016, second highest drop, the high pressure is less high, and the heat is along the Beaufort coast and the CAA. 2012 probably dropped as much as it did because of all the thin ice melting out in the Bering, because SLP-SAT looks less bad than 2019. The latter didn't lose as much volume as 2010 and 2016 because the high pressure is more towards Greenland and the heat is in the CAB, not along coasts.
My interpretation for May 16-31:
2012 lost the most volume, mostly because of a strong Dipole. 2010 and 2019 are on a par. 2019 has higher pressure (but again centred near Greenland), but 2010 has all the anomalous heat along all coasts. I would've guessed volume loss for 2016 would be higher, but maybe just not enough high pressure and anomalous heat.
BTW, this is high-level eyeballing. I may have to buy a pair of glasses now.