A post by Vox_Mundi in the what's new in the Arctic thread brings us back to an ASIF discussion from Jan 2022. Copying it here for wider visibility as I think the study is very interesting.
Study Shows That Strongest Arctic Cyclone On Record Led to Surprising Loss of Sea Icehttps://phys.org/news/2022-11-strongest-arctic-cyclone-loss-sea.htmlThe strongest Arctic cyclone ever observed poleward of 70 degrees north latitude struck in January 2022 northeast of Greenland. A new analysis led by the University of Washington shows that while weather forecasts accurately predicted the storm,
ice models seriously underestimated its impact on the region's sea ice.The study, published in October in the
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, suggests that existing models underestimate the impact of big waves on ice floes in the Arctic Ocean.
"The loss of sea ice in six days was the biggest change we could find in the historical observations since 1979, and the area of ice lost was 30% greater than the previous record," said lead author Ed Blanchard-Wrigglesworth, a research assistant professor of atmospheric sciences at the UW. "The ice models did predict some loss, but only about half of what we saw in the real world."
The January 2022 cyclone had the lowest pressure center estimated since satellite records began in 1979 above 70 degrees north (January 24 - 932.2 mb at 79.5°N 20°E.). It was an extreme version of a typical winter storm. Climate change doesn't appear responsible for the cyclone: The researchers didn't find a trend in the strength of intense Arctic cyclones since 1979, and sea ice area was close to the historical normal for that region before the storm hit.
During the storm, record winds howled over the Arctic Ocean. The waves grew to 8 meters (26 feet) tall in open water and remained surprisingly strong as they traveled through the sea ice.
The ice heaved 2 meters (6 feet) up and down near the edge of the pack, and NASA's ICESat-2 satellite shows that the waves reached as far as 100 kilometers (60 miles) toward the center of the ice pack.
Six days after the storm struck, the sea ice had thinned significantly in the affected waters north of Norway and Russia, in places losing more than half a meter (about 1.5 feet) of thickness.
The new analysis shows that the atmospheric heat from the storm had a small effect, meaning some other mechanism was to blame for the ice loss. Possibilities, Blanchard-Wrigglesworth suggests, include sea ice that was thinner before the storm hit than models had estimated; that the storm's waves broke up ice floes more forcefully than models predicted as they penetrated deep into the ice pack;
or that waves churned up deeper, warmer water and brought it into contact with the sea ice, melting the ice from below.The unexpected ice loss, despite an accurate storm forecast, suggests that this is an area where models could improve.
Edward Blanchard‐Wrigglesworth et al,
Record Arctic Cyclone of January 2022: Characteristics, Impacts, and Predictability,
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres (2022)
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2022JD037161------------------------------------------------
The ASIF discussion starts at:
https://forum.arctic-sea-ice.net/index.php/topic,3648.msg330257.html#msg330257